Comparative Study Summary – The Banshees of Inisherin
General Vision and Viewpoint
The film presents a bleak and tragic world, where friendship, loneliness, and human stubbornness lead to needless suffering. Set on a remote Irish island during the Irish Civil War, it explores how small conflicts can escalate into deep divisions. The story is darkly comedic, but its ultimate vision is pessimistic, suggesting that misunderstanding, pride, and isolation can destroy relationships and lead to irreversible consequences.
Cultural Context
Set in 1923 on the fictional island of Inisherin, the film reflects the social isolation, rigid traditions, and repressed emotions of rural Irish life. The background of the Irish Civil War mirrors the pointless feud between Pádraic and Colm, showing how stubbornness and conflict can escalate without clear reason. The film also explores religion, masculinity, and mental health, showing how community expectations and loneliness shape individual choices.
Theme or Issue
The film explores themes of friendship and isolation, conflict and stubbornness, loneliness, and the absurdity of human behaviour. Pádraic and Colm’s falling-out highlights how pride and a refusal to communicate can turn a small disagreement into a life-altering tragedy. The film also examines self-worth and purpose, as Colm seeks legacy through art, while Pádraic values kindness and companionship. The lack of resolution in their conflict leaves the audience with a tragic yet darkly humorous vision of human nature