In the Waiting Room – Elizabeth Bishop – Leaving Cert English

Context

“In the Waiting Room” was published in Elizabeth Bishop’s final collection, Geography III (1976). The poem describes a childhood experience: the young Elizabeth, nearly seven years old, sits in a dentist’s waiting room while her aunt is being treated. While looking through a copy of National Geographic magazine, the child has a sudden, overwhelming experience of self-awareness. She realises, with a shock, that she is a separate person, that she is connected to other human beings (including strangers in the magazine), and that she will grow up to be a woman like her aunt. This moment of existential awakening is one of the most famous passages in modern poetry. Bishop wrote it decades after the event, but the poem captures the child’s perspective with remarkable immediacy.

Summary

The poem is set on a winter evening in Worcester, Massachusetts, in February 1918. The young Elizabeth accompanies her Aunt Consuelo to the dentist. While waiting, she reads a National Geographic and looks at photographs of volcanoes, explorers and African women. Suddenly, she hears a cry of pain from inside the dentist’s room and realises it is her aunt’s voice. But then she is not sure whether the cry came from her aunt or from herself. This moment triggers a crisis of identity. The child feels the room sliding beneath her. She becomes intensely aware of her own existence, her connection to other people, and the strangeness of being alive. She steadies herself by focusing on concrete details: the date, her age, the fact that it is winter. The poem ends with the child returning to the waiting room, the world reassembled but permanently changed.

Analysis

The Waiting Room and the Magazine

The poem opens in a carefully established setting: a dentist’s waiting room, a specific date, a specific age. Bishop grounds the extraordinary experience to come in the most ordinary of circumstances. The child’s reading of National Geographic is described in detail. She sees volcanoes, explorers, and photographs of African women. These images of the wider world introduce the theme of human connection across vast distances. The child is confronted with the fact that she belongs to the same species as these people, that she shares something fundamental with them despite every surface difference.

The Cry and the Crisis

The pivotal moment comes when the child hears a cry from inside the dentist’s room. She attributes it to her aunt, but then becomes confused about whether the cry was actually her own. This blurring of boundaries between self and other is the heart of the poem’s existential crisis. If she cannot tell her own voice from her aunt’s, what does it mean to be a separate person? The room seems to slide and tip. The child feels herself falling into a terrifying awareness of her own existence. Bishop captures the vertigo of this moment brilliantly. The child’s world is coming apart at the seams, and she does not yet have the language or concepts to process what is happening.

The Questions

The child asks a series of urgent questions. Why should she be “one of them”? What connects her to these other people? Why is she here, in this body, at this time? These are the fundamental questions of human existence, rendered with astonishing freshness because they are experienced for the first time by a child. Bishop does not answer the questions. The poem’s power comes from the questions themselves and from the raw, unmediated quality of the child’s experience. The lack of answers is the point: these are questions that remain unanswerable throughout life.

The Return

The poem’s closing lines bring the child back to the solid world. She focuses on facts: the date, the place, the season. These concrete details anchor her after the vertiginous experience. The waiting room reassembles itself around her. But the reader understands that nothing is quite the same. The child has crossed a threshold. She has become aware of herself as a person in the world, connected to other people and subject to time. The final mention of the cold, dark winter evening outside creates a mood of both recovery and lingering strangeness.

Literary Devices

First-person narration: The poem is told in the first person, from the child’s perspective. This creates immediacy and intimacy. We experience the crisis as the child does, from the inside, without the buffer of adult analysis or explanation.

Enjambment: Bishop uses enjambment throughout to create a breathless, tumbling quality that mirrors the child’s disorientation. Lines spill into one another as the child’s certainties collapse.

Concrete detail: The specific date (February 1918), the child’s age (nearly seven), the National Geographic, the winter darkness outside are all grounding details. They anchor the abstract, existential experience in physical reality, a characteristic Bishop technique.

Repetition: The repeated questions (“Why should I be my aunt,” “What similarities”) create a sense of urgency and bewilderment. The child is grasping at understanding and failing to find it, and the repetition captures this struggle.

Imagery: The images from the National Geographic (volcanoes, African women, explorers) function as catalysts for the child’s awakening. They represent the vast, strange, interconnected human world that the child is suddenly aware of belonging to.

Mood

The mood begins as ordinary and slightly bored, capturing the experience of a child waiting in a dull room. It shifts dramatically at the moment of the cry, becoming disorienting, vertiginous and frightening. The child’s existential crisis creates a mood of almost overwhelming intensity. The questions that follow are urgent and bewildered. The closing lines bring a mood of recovery, but it is fragile. The world has been put back together, but the child (and the reader) know it can come apart again. There is wonder mixed with the fear, a sense of having glimpsed something enormous and not fully understood.

Themes

Identity and self-awareness: The poem’s central theme is the moment when a child first becomes aware of herself as a separate person. This awakening is both thrilling and terrifying, and Bishop captures it with extraordinary precision.

Connection and belonging: The child realises she is connected to other human beings, including strangers in a magazine. This sense of belonging to the human race is overwhelming because it means she shares in all of humanity’s experiences, not just the comfortable ones.

Gender and growing up: The child’s realisation that she will become a woman like her aunt introduces the theme of gender. The prospect of growing up and taking on an adult female identity is part of what frightens and disorients her.

The strangeness of existence: At its deepest level, the poem is about the sheer strangeness of being alive. The child’s questions are the questions philosophy has asked for centuries, but Bishop makes them feel fresh and urgent by filtering them through a child’s unfiltered experience.

Exam Pitfalls

Pitfall 1: Retelling the story without analysis. This poem has a strong narrative, and it is tempting to simply summarise the plot. Always connect the events to the poem’s themes and techniques. What does the cry mean? Why does the room slide?

Pitfall 2: Ignoring the child’s perspective. The poem’s power comes from its use of a child’s viewpoint. Discuss how Bishop captures the child’s bewilderment and inability to fully process what is happening.

Pitfall 3: Missing the gender dimension. The child’s fear is partly about becoming a woman. The images of the African women in the magazine and the thought of becoming “one of them” include a gender component that should be addressed.

Rapid Revision Drills

Drill 1 (Recall): What triggers the child’s crisis of identity?
Answer: Hearing a cry from the dentist’s room that she attributes to her aunt, then being unable to tell whether the cry came from her aunt or from herself. This blurring of boundaries triggers an overwhelming awareness of her own existence and connection to others.

Drill 2 (Quote + Technique): How does Bishop use concrete detail in this poem?
Answer: Bishop anchors the existential crisis in specific facts: the date (February 1918), the child’s age (nearly seven), the National Geographic, the winter darkness. These details ground the abstract experience in physical reality and prevent the poem from becoming vague or overly philosophical.

Drill 3 (Theme Link): How does the theme of identity operate in this poem?
Answer: The child discovers her own identity by realising she is both separate from and connected to other people. The crisis is that identity is not simple: she is herself, but she is also “one of them,” connected to her aunt, to the women in the magazine, to all of humanity. This discovery is both a gain and a loss of certainty.

Conclusion

“In the Waiting Room” is one of the essential Bishop poems for the Leaving Cert. It combines Bishop’s characteristic precision with an extraordinary depth of philosophical and emotional content. For exam answers, focus on the moment of crisis (the cry), the child’s perspective, the existential questions, and Bishop’s technique of grounding abstract experience in concrete detail. This is a poem about what it means to become aware of yourself as a human being, and it is one of the most powerful treatments of that theme in modern poetry.

Want notes and structures for every text on the course? Start your free trial →